Skip to content
Illustration of a magnifying glass, notebook and coloured speech bubbles
English 5 min read October 31, 2026
English

11+ Fact and Opinion: Evidence, Claims and Practice

Distinguish facts, factual claims and opinions using an original notice, mixed statements and explained questions.

“The hall has eight windows” is a factual claim: counting the windows can test it. “The hall is beautiful” is an opinion: it expresses a judgement. A factual claim can be wrong, so being checkable does not automatically make a statement true.

These original activities support preparation for 11-plus exams taken in 2027. They are not official exam questions or a complete school syllabus. Try the tasks before opening the answers; English model answers allow other accurate wording.

Separate the type of claim from its accuracy

In comprehension, a question may ask what a passage presents as a fact. Answer from the passage, while recognising that real-world verification would require evidence. An incorrect numerical claim remains a factual claim, not a personal preference. Opinions can be supported by reasons without becoming objectively established facts.

Original fictional notice

“The village reading room opens at 9 am on Saturdays. It has twelve chairs and two long tables. Last Saturday, eight visitors borrowed books. The room is the most welcoming place in the village. I think it should stay open later,” wrote the club secretary, Mira.

For these exercises, treat the opening time, furniture and visitor count as details supplied by the fictional notice. The passage is not a report about a real reading room. The claim about being “most welcoming” is a judgement, and the proposed later opening is a recommendation.

Clue words help, but do not decide everything

Words such as wonderful, dull and best often signal evaluation. However, an opinion does not need “I think”: “This is the best room” is still a judgement. Conversely, “Mira said she liked the room” reports an event that could be checked against a recording, while the liking itself is her preference. Keep the reporting claim separate from the opinion being reported.

Numbers can occur in opinions too: “The room needs three more chairs” is a recommendation unless a specific requirement establishes that need. Ask what the sentence asserts, not just whether it contains digits. A reason beginning “because” also does not automatically prove the judgement it supports.

A sentence can mix both

“The room has twelve chairs and is the nicest place to read” combines a checkable count with a preference. Split the sentence into its claims. If asked to copy the opinion, copy only the relevant wording rather than including the factual part unnecessarily.

Original practice

Which notice detail could you check by counting furniture?

Show answer and explanation

It has twelve chairs and two long tables.

These quantities can be compared with the room’s contents.

Copy the wording that expresses a judgement about the room.

Show answer and explanation

“the most welcoming place in the village”

Welcoming is evaluated differently by different people; the superlative is not established by the stated counts.

Is the later-opening sentence a fact or an opinion?

Show answer and explanation

An opinion or recommendation.

It says what Mira thinks should happen, not what currently happens.

Someone says the notice states ten visitors borrowed books. What is wrong?

Show answer and explanation

The notice says eight, not ten.

The claim is contradicted by the supplied text. It is not merely a difference of preference.

Separate the claims: “The room has two tables and is far too small.”

Show answer and explanation

Two tables is a factual claim; “far too small” is a judgement.

The count can be checked. Too small depends on the purpose and criteria being applied.

Does “I think the room opens at 9 am” necessarily express a preference?

Show answer and explanation

No.

It expresses uncertainty about a checkable opening time, rather than liking or recommending that time.

Explain your classification

A useful answer names the claim and the test: count the chairs, check the timetable, or recognise a personal judgement. Avoid saying merely “it sounds true”. When evidence is missing, say what would be needed instead of inventing proof.

What to practise next

Return to the English hub, then practise vocabulary in context and using evidence. Browse the practice directory for further work.

Source and answer checks

The Department for Education programme of study provides the curriculum foundation. School entrance requirements vary. Examples and passages here are original; worked answers were checked against the calculations or the supplied text. No external educator endorsement is claimed.

Ready to practise?

Choose original practice and use the answer explanations to decide what to work on next. These are not official school papers.